Legal Bases for a Will Contest

If you're considering challenging a Will, it's important to understand the most common reasons for doing so. Here’s a breakdown of the key grounds for contesting a will that we often see in our practice.

Will contests are an unfortunate part of probate litigation, especially in cases where a significant amount of money is involved. These disputes can be emotionally taxing and financially draining.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

One of the most common reasons to contest a Will is to argue that the testator (the person who made the will) lacked testamentary capacity at the time they signed the document. Testamentary capacity refers to the mental ability to understand what they were doing when creating the Will. This argument often arises when the testator is suffering from conditions like Alzheimer’s or dementia. However, it’s important to note that this challenge focuses on the testator’s mental state at the exact time the will was executed – not before or after.

Undue Influence

Another frequent basis for contesting a will is undue influence. This occurs when someone close to the testator (usually a family member) uses their relationship to manipulate or coerce the testator into creating or altering the will in a way that benefits them. The key factor here is that the testator’s decisions were not entirely their own but were influenced by someone abusing their position of trust. This often happens when the testator is in a vulnerable state and relies heavily on the person exerting influence.

Multiple Wills or Codicils

Another situation that can lead to a Will contest involves multiple wills or codicils (amendments to a will). If a will is presented for probate, but there is evidence that a more recent will or codicil exists, this can form the basis for a challenge. The goal is to ensure that the court recognizes the most up-to-date and valid version of the testator’s wishes.

Preparing for a Will Contest

Will contests can be incredibly expensive and time-consuming. You need to be prepared for the financial and emotional costs of litigation. It’s important to consult with an experienced attorney who can guide you through the process, gather the necessary evidence, and represent your interests effectively.

If you have questions about a will contest in Tennessee, or if you’re considering contesting a will, please don’t hesitate to contact us. We can help you understand your options and what to expect.

douglass runger justice icon

FAQ's

Can a minor receive an inheritance in Tennessee?
Probate Law
Curt Runger of Memphis law firm Douglass & Runger answers the question of if a minor can receive an inheritance...
Do I Have to Open an Estate if all I Inherited in a Will was Real Estate?
Probate Law
Learn how to handle probate when a loved one leaves behind only real estate with attorney Curt Runger.
How Much Do Will Contest Lawsuits Cost?
Probate Law
Will contests are expensive and should only be pursued if a significant amount of money is at stake and you...
Legal Bases for a Will Contest
Probate Law
Curt Runger of Memphis law firm Douglass & Runger explains legal bases for a will contest.
Should You Pay a Loved One’s Bills After They Pass Away?
Probate Law
Wondering if you should pay a loved one’s bills after they pass away? Learn why it’s usually better to let...
What are the Duties of a Personal Representative aka an Executor or Administrator in Tennessee?
Estate Planning
Learn the essential duties of a personal representative aka an Executor or Administrator in probate, from managing assets to notifying...
What is an inventory and when do I have to file one?
Probate Law
Learn about the probate inventory process, including what it is, why it’s important, and when you might not need to...
What is the Process for Opening a Probate Estate in Tennessee?
Probate Law
Learn how to open an estate with guidance from Douglass & Runger. Schedule a consultation today to discuss your probate...
When do you need to open a probate estate in Tennessee?
Probate Law
The main consideration is whether there are assets titled solely in the deceased's name. If so, an estate likely needs...
Who has standing to file a Will contest?
Probate Law
Learn about legal standing for filing a will contest in Tennessee. Discover who can challenge a will and why having...

Related Practice Areas

Guardianships
Guardianship is about ensuring the future care of your loved one. Douglass & Runger helps you navigate the legal process with clarity and compassion.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue
Intestate Estate Administration
When a loved one passes away without a Will, the estate enters into a legal process known as intestate estate administration.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue
Probate Law
Probate is a legal and financial process that takes place after someone dies, and involves managing their estate. This includes organizing their assets, money, and possessions, and distributing them as inheritance to their beneficiaries after paying any debts and taxes.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue
Probating A Will
When a loved one passes away with a Will, it must go through probate to be legally recognized. This process ensures their assets are distributed according to their wishes, debts are paid, and the estate is settled properly.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue
Trust Administration
Trust administration involves managing the assets within the Trust, paying debts and taxes, and distributing assets to beneficiaries according to the terms set by the grantor.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue
Trust Litigation
Without proper legal guidance, Trust disputes can escalate quickly, leading to emotional stress, financial loss, and strained family relationships. Trust Litigation ensures that these conflicts are handled fairly and according to the law.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue
Will Contests
A will contest is a legal challenge to the validity of a will. These disputes often arise when an heir or beneficiary believes the will does not accurately reflect the deceased's intentions or was executed under questionable circumstances.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue
Will Preparation
Will preparation ensures your wishes are honored and your loved ones aren’t left with uncertainty or legal headaches. It’s a simple way to provide clarity and peace of mind for the future.
douglass runger map pin icon arrow right blue

Related Blogs

Long-Term Care Is Expensive – Qualified Income Trust (QIT) Can Help

Many of us will need additional care as we age, so a competent estate planning attorney will strongly encourage you to prepare for your future.

Why Estate Plan Disputes Head to Court

When estate plan disputes go to court, it’s often due to unclear language, competing beneficiary interests, or excluded heirs. This article explores the key reasons such conflicts escalate into legal battles—and what you can do to avoid them.